Updated

League Cup · Round of 16

Everton vs Newcastle United

· Hill Dickinson Stadium, Liverpool· Referee Farai Hallam

Full time3 – 1

Alin prediction was Everton to win

Ablended with market oddsCorrect

Predicted score 2 – 1

9% — likeliest score with our pick

Win probability
EvertonDrawNewcastle United

Why this pick: Everton vs Newcastle United

Model inputs: per-match averages over each side's last 10 played matches (Everton 10, Newcastle United 10). PPDA — lower means more intense pressing.

EvertonNewcastle United
1.41 xG per 90 1.14
1.41 npxG per 90 1.05
14.1 PPDA 9.9
6.0 Deep completions per 90 6.3
1.23 xPTS per 90 0.86

xG and npxG (non-penalty) per match, deep completions (passes received within ~20 yards of goal) and xPTS (expected points) from Understat match data. Bold marks the stronger side on each line.

Everton vs Newcastle United: model vs market

1X2 probabilities: our model, the de-vigged market and the published blend
SourceEvertonDrawNewcastle United
Model42%26%32%
Market42%27%32%
Published42%27%32%
Edge0%0%0%

Edge = our published probability minus the de-vigged market probability. Published = the blend of both that backs every number on this page.

Everton vs Newcastle United odds movement

Median bookmaker price on Everton, 84 snapshots since 2026-09-18.

Opened 2.35Now 2.28 -0.07
Median 1X2 prices, first and latest snapshot
SelectionFirstLatestMove
Everton2.352.28-0.07
Draw3.403.54+0.14
Newcastle United2.853.00+0.15

A shortening price means the market has moved towards that outcome. Median across all recorded bookmakers, not one book's line.

Everton and Newcastle United expected goals

The goal rate the model gives each side in this fixture, from xG-based attack and defence ratings.

1.64Everton
1.41Newcastle United
Total expected goals
3.05
Attack rating (Everton / Newcastle United)
1.05 / 0.96
Defence rating (Everton / Newcastle United)
0.98 / 1.09

Ratings are relative to the league average (1.00); lower defence rating = fewer goals conceded per match.

Everton vs Newcastle United score probability

Every scoreline the model gives this match, 0 to 4+ goals a side. Darker = likelier.

01234+ 0 5.9% 5.6% 4.7% 2.2% 1.1% 1 6.7% 12.1% 7.7% 3.6% 1.7% 2 6.4% 9.0% 6.3% 3.0% 1.4% 3 3.5% 4.9% 3.5% 1.6% 0.8% 4+ 2.1% 2.9% 2.0% 1.0% 0.5%

Rows: Everton goals. Columns: Newcastle United goals. Outlined cell = most likely scoreline.

Everton vs Newcastle United goals probability

Chance of the match clearing each total, read off the same score matrix as the heatmap.

Over 0.5 94%
Over 1.5 82%
Over 2.5 59%
Over 3.5 36%
Both teams to score
62%
No goals (0–0)
6%

Over 4.5 and higher fall inside the 4+ buckets and cannot be read off a 0–4 grid, so they are not shown.

All markets for Everton vs Newcastle United

Published probability and fair odds per market
MarketSelectionProbabilityFair odds
1X2Everton42%2.40
Draw27%3.76
Newcastle United32%3.16
Over/Under 2.5Over 2.559%1.70
Under 2.541%2.42
Both teams to scoreYes62%1.61
No38%2.63
Double chance1X (Everton or draw)68%1.46
12 (either side)73%1.36
X2 (draw or Newcastle United)58%1.72
Handicap -1Everton win by 2+22%4.52
Push (exactly one goal)20%—

Fair odds = 1 / probability — the break-even price implied by the published probability. Correct-score probabilities are on the heatmap above.

Everton and Newcastle United recent form

Everton 2W 2D 2L
Newcastle United 3W 0D 3L

Last 6 completed matches, all competitions, newest on the right.

Home vs away this season

Everton at home

Record (W-D-L)
1-0-0
Win rate
100%
Goals for / match
1.00
Goals against / match
0.00
Clean sheets
1 of 1

Newcastle United away

Record (W-D-L)
1-0-0
Win rate
100%
Goals for / match
1.00
Goals against / match
0.00
Clean sheets
1 of 1

League matches this season before kick-off: Everton at home only, Newcastle United away only.

Expected lineups

Everton lineup · 4-2-3-1

  1. 1 J. Pickford
  2. 16 V. Mykolenko
  3. 15 J. O'Brien
  4. 6 J. Tarkowski
  5. 34 M. Röhl
  6. 37 J. Garner
  7. 30 H. Hackney
  8. 19 Tyrique George
  9. 8 K. Dewsbury-Hall
  10. 20 T. Dibling
  11. 11 T. Barry

Bench: A. Maitland-Niles, M. Keane, M. Travers, B. Johnson, C. Nørgaard, C. Alcaraz, T. King, H. Armstrong, B. Graham

Newcastle United lineup · 4-2-3-1

  1. 21 L. Horníček
  2. 3 L. Hall
  3. 33 D. Burn
  4. 5 F. Schär
  5. 37 A. Dedić
  6. 41 J. Ramsey
  7. 6 Nico González
  8. 11 H. Barnes
  9. 28 J. Willock
  10. 23 J. Murphy
  11. 10 W. Osula

Bench: N. Pope, S. Botman, Joelinton, A. Bamba, Y. Wissa, M. Thiaw, Sean Steur, B. Touré, A. Elanga

Everton vs Newcastle United head-to-head

Last 10 meetings: Everton 5 · draws 2 · Newcastle United 3.

EvertonDrawsNewcastle United
Previous meetings
DateHomeScoreAwayCompetition
2026-08-12Newcastle United1-3EvertonFriendlies Clubs
2026-02-28Newcastle United2-3EvertonPremier League
2025-11-29Everton1-4Newcastle UnitedPremier League
2025-05-25Newcastle United0-1EvertonPremier League
2024-10-05Everton0-0Newcastle UnitedPremier League
2024-04-02Newcastle United1-1EvertonPremier League
2023-12-07Everton3-0Newcastle UnitedPremier League
2023-04-27Everton1-4Newcastle UnitedPremier League
2022-10-19Newcastle United1-0EvertonPremier League
2022-03-17Everton1-0Newcastle UnitedPremier League

Other Round of 16 fixtures

Before and after this match